Montana State Legislature
2015-2016 Judicial Redistricting Commission
About the Judicial Redistricting Commission
House Bill 430 (2015) created a seven-member Judicial Redistricting Commission. The bill required the commission to study whether judicial redistricting is necessary using the following factors:
- the population of the judicial districts as determined by the latest figures prepared and issued by the United States Census Bureau;
- each judicial district's weighted caseload as determined by judicial workload studies;
- the relative proportions of civil, criminal, juvenile, and family law cases in each judicial district;
- the extent to which special masters, alternative dispute resolution techniques, and other measures have been used in the judicial districts;
- the distances in highway miles between county seats in existing judicial districts and any judicial districts that may be proposed by the commission;
- the impact on counties of any changes proposed in the judicial districts; and
- any other factors that the commission considers significant to the determination of whether the state's judicial districts should be redistricted.
The Judicial Redistricting Commission met four times between September 2015 and August 2016. After disscussion, the commission voted against recommending any of the six redistricting proposals it considered to the 2017 Legislature and determined that redistricting is not necessary and not the appropriate way to address the need for additional judges.
- REPRESENTATIVE NATE MCCONNELL (D)
- SENATOR KRISTIN HANSEN (R)
Public Members
- Honorable Greg Todd - CHAIR
- Honorable Ray Dayton
- Rick Cook: Clerk of District Court, Chouteau County
- Dave Schulz: Commissioner, Madison County
- Emily Jones, State Bar Member
Judicial Redistricting Commission Topics
Final Report
Study Resources
County And District Populations
- Montana county population estimates -- Census and Economic Information Center, Montana Department of Commerce
- County populations: table and map -- Legislative Services Division (LSD)
- Judicial district populations: table and map -- LSD
Caseload And Workload Data
- Montana District Court Judicial Weighted Caseload Study, 2014 -- National Center for State Courts
- Judicial Need Model (2014 weights/2014 filings) -- Office of the Court Administrator (OCA)
- Judicial Need Model (2015 weights/2015 filings) -- OCA
- District Court case filing statistics, 2014 -- OCA
- District Court case filing statistics, 2015 -- OCA
- 2016 District Court Case Filing Review -- OCA
- 2016 District Court Workload Review -- OCA
- Uniform caseload filing standards -- Montana Supreme Court
- Case types as percentage of workload: table and chart -- LSD
District Background And History
Other Maps
- Current Judicial Districts -- LSD
- Judicial Need by District, 2015 and 2014 -- LSD
- Total Travel by District, 2015 -- LSD
- Travel Per Judge by District, 2015 -- LSD
- Total Judicial Demand Per Allocated Judge -- LSD
- Judges' Home County Seats -- LSD
Presentation Materials
- Presentation slides: Office of the Court Administrator, September 2015
Additional Information
***The meeting will be conducted by teleconference. Members of the public who wish to attend or to give public comment must meet in Room 137 of the Capitol.
Meeting Materials
Other Background Documents
- Memo to commissioners about August meeting
- Public comment guidelines
Meeting Materials
- Map of current judicial districts -- Legislative Services Division (LSD)
- Summary of proposals with maps -- as of March 15
- Proposal 1
- Map
- Draft analysis packet (3/31 update)
- Bill draft language (LCjr01)
- Proposal 2
- Map
- Draft analysis packet (3/31 update)
- Bill draft language (LCjr02)
- Proposal 3
- Map
- Draft analysis packet (3/31 update)
- Bill draft language (LCjr03)
- Proposal 4
- Map
- Draft analysis packet (3/31 update)
- Bill draft language (LCjr04)
- Proposal 5
- Map
- Draft analysis packet
- Revised analysis packet (4/7)
- Bill draft language (LCjr05)
- Proposal 6
- Map
- Draft analysis packet
- Bill draft language (LCjr06)
- 2017 Biennium Budget Reports -- Legislative Fiscal Division (LFD)
Other Background Documents Or Materials
- Memo to commissioners about April meeting
- Legislative Fiscal Division Chart of the Week on Montana District Court Cases
- Public comment guidelines
- Link to Montana Drug Courts website
Meeting Materials
- Map of Current Judicial Districts -- Legislative Services Division (LSD)
- 2001-2002 summary of state statutes requiring timlines for district courts -- LSD
- 2016 District Court Case Filing Review -- Office of Court Administrator (OCA)
- 2016 District Court Workload Review -- Judicial Resource Needs -- OCA
- Judicial Need Model (2015 weights/2015 filings) -- OCA
- 2015 New Case Filings and Reopened Cases -- OCA
- Additional maps -- LSD
Other Background Documents
- 1st Judicial District civil case data
- Memo: Drug Treatment Courts -- LSD
- List of Montana treatment courts -- from OCA 2015 drug court report
- Montana Drug Courts: An Updated Snapshot of Success and Hope, 2015 -- OCA
- Executive Summary: The Multi-Site Adult Drug Court Evaluation, 2011 -- National Institute of Justice
- Research Update on Adult Drug Courts, 2010 -- National Association of Drug Court Professionals
- Memo to commissioners about February meeting
- Memo: Budget information request (posted 2/3)
- Public comment guidelines
- Text of House Bill No. 430
- Map of current judicial districts
- Montana judicial districts by the numbers
- Recent legislative history of Montana's judicial districts
- District Court judges' terms
- Presentation slides: Montana District Courts Caseload and Workload Information -- Office of the Court Administrator (OCA)
- Montana District Court Judicial Weighted Caseload Study, 2014
- District Court case filing statistics, 2014
- Uniform caseload filing standards
- Judicial Need Model (2014 weights/2014 filings)
- Draft Work Plan
- Additional maps, tables, and charts
- Map: Judicial need by district with current judges -- OCA
- Map: Judicial need by county workload -- OCA
- Table: County populations -- Legislative Services Division (LSD)
- Map: County populations -- LSD
- Table: Judicial district populations -- LSD
- Map: Judicial districts populations -- LSD
- Map: Judicial need by district -- LSD
- Map: Judicial need by county -- LSD
- Table: Casetypes as percentage of workload -- LSD
- Chart: Casetypes as percentage of workload -- LSD
- Public comment guidelines
- Memo to the commissioners about September meeting